Honest Maybelline Sky High Mascara Review – Is It Really Worth the Hype?
Introduction
Maybelline is no stranger to delivering iconic, affordable makeup—but every once in a while, a product truly captures the spotlight. Enter the Maybelline New York Lash Sensational Sky High Mascara—a mascara that has taken over TikTok, Instagram, and beauty blogs alike. But is it really worth the buzz?
As someone who runs a Canadian beauty blog and regularly tests Amazon beauty bestsellers, I had to find out for myself. Here’s my full Maybelline Sky High Mascara review, complete with testing, comparisons, pros and cons, and what real Canadian users are saying.
First Impressions: Packaging and Formula
Right out of the box, Sky High makes a bold first impression. Its rose-gold packaging with raised lettering is stylish and instantly recognizable.
The formula is enriched with bamboo extract and ultra-lightweight fibers that promise sky-high length and volume without flaking or smudging. It’s also ophthalmologist-tested and safe for sensitive eyes.
What’s Special About the Sky High Brush?
The most unique aspect of this mascara is its Flex Tower brush—a bendable, tapered wand designed to coat every single lash from root to tip.
At first, I was skeptical. Flexible wands can sometimes lack control. But this one surprised me with its ease of use and precision.
Application Test: My Experience
I tried this mascara in the “Very Black” shade on both bare lashes and over a lash primer. Here’s how it performed:
- First Coat: Immediate length, zero clumping
- Second Coat: Dramatic lift, great separation
- Third Coat: Still buildable, minimal smudging
Even after a full day of wear (including a humid Toronto commute), there was no smudging or flaking.
Maybelline Sky High vs Lash Sensational
While both mascaras are from the same Maybelline family, here’s a quick comparison:
| Feature | Sky High | Lash Sensational |
|---|---|---|
| Wand | Flexible, narrow | Curved, thick |
| Best For | Length and separation | Volume and curl |
| Formula | Lightweight fibers | Classic creamy formula |
| Wear | Smudge-resistant | Long-lasting |
| Verdict | Best for long, fluttery lashes | Better for full, dramatic volume |
Waterproof vs Washable: Which One Should You Choose?
Maybelline offers Sky High in both washable and waterproof formulas. If you need all-day hold through tears or heat, go waterproof. Otherwise, the washable version is more comfortable for daily wear and much easier to remove.
LSI Keyword Mention: If you’re looking for something that won’t budge all day, the Maybelline Sky High Waterproof might be your go-to.
What Users Are Saying (Real Reviews)
Here are highlights from verified Canadian customers:
Anna (★★★★★): “No more mascara smudges on my oily eyelids! This is buildable, easy to remove, and looks better than my old $30 mascara.”
Emma P. (★★★★): “It outperforms my Rare Beauty one! Just wish the wand was sturdier. Great value.”
Em (★★★★★): “The Burgundy shade is STUNNING. It’s my favorite mascara ever. Zero flakes.”
Jennifer (★★★★★): “Always my go-to. I’ve been through 5 tubes!”
My Honest Review
As someone who explores dozens of trending beauty products each month, this one really stood out.
I personally tested this mascara for a week. The brush felt a little odd at first, but I quickly got used to it. What impressed me most was the balance between volume and definition—something many mascaras fail to deliver.
There’s no flaking, and I can wear it all day without raccoon eyes—even in warm weather. Removing it is simple with micellar water, and I never experienced any irritation.
⭐ My Rating: 9.5/10
❓ Would I repurchase? Absolutely.
Pros & Cons at a Glance
Pros ✅
- Lightweight, flake-free formula
- Extreme length and separation
- Buildable without clumps
- Easy to remove (washable version)
- Affordable and widely available
Cons ❌
- Flexible wand may feel flimsy for some
- Some shades can be hard to find
- May not give intense volume like other mascaras
Tips for Best Results
- Start with a lash primer (like Maybelline Sky High Lash Primer) for added volume
- Wiggle the brush from root to tip for better separation
- Let each coat dry slightly before applying another to avoid clumps
- Use a clean dry spoolie to separate if needed
How to Remove Sky High Mascara
For a gentle removal that doesn’t irritate your eyes:
🧴 Use Garnier Micellar Water
🧻 Apply with a cotton pad, press gently for 10 seconds, then wipe
Final Verdict: Should You Buy It?
If you’re looking for a lengthening mascara that won’t smudge, clump, or weigh your lashes down, Maybelline Sky High delivers on its promise. It’s versatile enough for everyday use, yet bold enough for special occasions.
For Canadian women seeking affordable luxury in their beauty routine, this mascara is a smart buy-especially when you can grab it directly from Amazon.
Don’t Miss Out: Your Lashes Deserve This Lift
Ready to give your lashes the drama they deserve? Try Maybelline Sky High Mascara and see why thousands of Canadian women are making the switch.